Homepage Blank Review Commercial Appraisal PDF Form
Content Overview

The Review Commercial Appraisal form serves as a comprehensive tool for evaluating the accuracy and reliability of appraisal reports related to commercial properties. It encompasses several critical sections designed to assess various elements of the appraisal process, including property identification, ownership details, and assessment history. The form prompts reviewers to consider the purpose and function of the appraisal, allowing them to specify the value sought—whether market value or another type—and to clarify the date of that value. Furthermore, it requires a thorough analysis of the property’s location, physical characteristics, and highest and best use, ensuring that all relevant zoning and market conditions are taken into account. Reviewers must also evaluate the methodologies employed in determining property value, including the cost approach, income capitalization, and sales comparison approaches. Each section contains specific questions and checkboxes, guiding the reviewer through a systematic evaluation of the appraisal's strengths and weaknesses. By collecting detailed information and providing structured feedback, this form ultimately aids in ensuring that commercial appraisals are both accurate and credible.

Document Preview

COMMERCIAL APPRAISAL REVIEW FORM

The appraisal report which is the subject of this review is briefly identified and described as follows:

Name of Project/Property __________________________________________________________________________________________

Location/Legal __________________________________________________________________________________________________

Type of propert ____________________________________________________________________ ❐ Existing ❐ Proposed Construction

Name of Appraiser _________________________________________________________________ Telephone ____________________

Address

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________

Report Addressed to: _______________________________________________________________ Telephone ____________________

Address

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________

Type of Appraisal Report: ❐ Narrative ❐ Printed Form ❐ Other (identify) ___________________________________________________

Section I — Purpose and Function of Appraisal

Value Sought:

❐ Market Value

❐ Other (identify)

Date of value:

❐ Current

❐ Future

❐ Past

 

 

______________

Definitions Given For:

❐ Value Sought

❐ Interest To Be Valued

Interests Valued:

❐ Fee Simple

❐ Leased Interest

 

❐ Market Rent

❐ Other (identify)

 

❐ Easements

❐ Other (identify)

 

 

__________________

 

 

______________

Assumptions and

❐ Standard

❐ Consistent with

Real Estate Valued

❐ Land

❐ Improvements

Limiting Conditions:

 

Valuation Process

 

❐ Ground Lease

❐ Personal Property

 

❐ Third Party

❐ Unreasonable or

 

❐ Other (identify)_______________

 

Report

Excessive

 

Comments:

 

 

 

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section II — Property Identification, Ownership and Assessment

Does the report adequately contain or identify:

Yes

No

N/A

 

 

Yes

No N/A

 

Property Location/Address:

Owners of Record

 

Legal Description

History of Ownership

 

 

 

 

Real Estate Tax Information

If Applicable to Subject Property:

 

 

 

 

Assessments, Bonds, etc.

Amount of Purchase Price

$____________

Existence of:

 

 

 

Pending Sales Price

$____________

Deed Restrictions

Asking Price

$____________

Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions

Option Price

$____________

Moratoriums

Other

$____________

Comments:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section III — Location Analysis

Does the report adequately describe or identify:

Does report:

 

Region

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Sum up and rate the above area

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

City

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Identify and discuss important trends

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Neighborhood

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Identify nuisances or hazards

❐ Yes ❐ No ❐ N/A

Comments:

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section IV — Property Description

Comment upon the descriptions and analysis of the following:

IMPROVEMENTS:

 

SITE:

 

Adequate description of physical features ❐ Yes ❐ No

Adequate description of physical features❐ Yes ❐ No

Attention given to:

 

Identification of encumbrances

❐Yes ❐ No

Quality

❐ Yes ❐ No

Does the report state adequacy of site for

 

Functional Utility and Appeal

❐ Yes ❐ No

existing or proposed use

❐Yes ❐ No

Age

❐ Yes ❐ No

Utilities available

❐Yes ❐ No

Condition

❐ Yes ❐ No

Special Problems:

 

Hazardous Conditions

❐ Yes ❐ No

Flood

❐Yes ❐ No

ZONING:

 

Environmental Hazards, Seismic, Toxic etc.

Statement

❐ Yes ❐ No

Other (identify)_________________

❐Yes ❐ No

Definition

❐ Yes ❐ No

Comments:

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section V — Highest and Best Use

Definition

❐ Yes ❐ No

Does property conform to zoning and

 

Components

❐ Yes ❐ No

neighborhood

❐ Yes ❐ No

Conclusion of Highest and Best Use______________________

Is use legal and physically possible

❐ Yes ❐ No

Current zoning ______________________________________

Has the report in this or other sections discussed:

Status zoning change _________________________________

Marketability (supply-demand, market trends,

Status of building permit (if possible construction) ____________

absorption occupancy levels)

❐ Yes ❐ No

Does report discuss feasibility/profitability

❐ Yes ❐ No

Other (identify) ____________________________________

 

 

Were other studies/reports considered

❐ Yes ❐No

Comments:

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Copyright © by the National Association of Review Appraisers and Mortgage Underwriters 1224 North Nokomis NE, Alexandria, Minnesota,USA. This formReview Form No. 4002 may be reproduced without written consent, however, the “National Association of Review Appraisers and Mortgage Underwriter’s must be acknowledged and credited.

SECTION VI — Property Valuation

Comment and rate the approaches to value:

 

 

 

 

COST APPROACH:

Satisfactory

Unsatisfactory

DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW ANALYSIS (DCF)

 

Format

 

 

Satisfactory

Unsatisfactory

Adequacy of data

 

Format

Source of costs

 

Adequacy of data and support for:

 

Land value estimate

 

Holding Period

Estimated cost new

 

Growth Rates

Depreciation estimate

 

Discount Rate

SALES COMPARISON APPROACH:

 

Development of Cash Flow Estimates ❐

Format

 

Reversionary Value

Adequacy of data

 

Other Methods of Processing Income

 

Sources of data

 

Stream (Mortgage Equity, Band of

 

Summary of sales table

 

Investments, etc.)

Use of adjustment grid table

RECONCILIATION:

 

 

Comparative analysis of sales

Indicated values are:

 

 

INCOME CAPITALIZATION APPROACH:

 

Cost Approach

$ __________

 

Format

 

Sales Comparison Approach

$ __________

 

Selection of proper capitalization

 

Income Approach

$ __________

 

method

 

DCF Analysis

$ __________

 

Adequacy of data and support for:

 

 

Other (Pending Sale, etc.)

 

 

Comparable Rentals

 

Value Conclusion

 

$ ________

Vacancy and Loss Factor

 

Allocation as Follows:

 

 

Operating History

 

Land

$ __________

 

Rent Roll

 

Improvements

$ __________

 

Income Estimate

 

Personal Property

$ __________

 

Expense Estimate

 

Other

$ __________

 

Net Operating Income

 

Total Value

 

$ ________

Capitalization Rate

 

 

 

 

Comments:

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section VII — Other Report Requirements

Does the report contain a certification ❐ Yes

❐ No

Does the principal appraiser make

 

 

Is the report co-signed

❐ Yes

❐ No

statement of concurrence with value

 

 

Did the principal appraiser sign the

 

conclusion

❐ Yes

❐ No

report

❐ Yes

❐ No

Does the report contain appraiser(s)

 

 

Did the principal appraiser personally

 

qualifications

❐ Yes

❐ No

inspect subject property

❐ Yes

❐ No

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Section VIII — Final Rating of Appraisal

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Acceptable

Unacceptable

 

Acceptable

Unacceptable

Report Format

 

 

Property Valuation:

 

 

Readability and neatness

Feasibility/Profitability

Mathematical accuracy

Market Trends

Exhibits (Photos, Maps, etc.)

Cost Approach

Appraiser’s analytical ability

Sales Comparison Approach

Purpose and function of appraisal ❐

Income Approach

Property identification

DCF

Locational analysis

Reconciliation

Property Description

Date of Appraisal

Site

Overall Rating of Appraisal

 

 

Improvements

 

 

 

Highest and Best Use

 

 

 

Brief Comments on Unacceptable Ratings:

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Section IX — Reviewer’s Conclusions — Recommendations

Scope of Review:

 

 

If reviewer does not concur with the soundness if conclusion, then

Read report

❐ Yes

❐ No

what is the recommended action:

Interviewed appraiser

❐ Yes

❐ No

❐ Totally reject appraisal

Field Review

❐ Yes

❐ No

❐ Have appraiser rework, revise, update the appraisal

Does the Reviewer concur with

 

 

❐ Have another appraisal prepared by someone else

the soundness of conclusion:

❐ Yes

❐ No

❐ Other

Concluding Comments:

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Reviewer’s Signature _____________________________________________________________________________________________

Name of Reviewer __________________________________________________________________ Date ________________________

Position ___________________________________________________________________________ Department __________________

Address __________________________________________________________________________ Telephone ___________________

City, State, Zip __________________________________________________________________________________________________

Copyright © by the National Association of Review Appraisers and Mortgage Underwriters P.O. Box 879, Palm Springs, California, 92263 USA. This form

Review Form No. 4002

may be reproduced without written consent, however, the “National Association of Review Appraisers and Mortgage Underwriter’s must be acknowledged and credited.

 

Form Specifications

Fact Name Description
Purpose of the Form The Review Commercial Appraisal form is designed to evaluate the quality and accuracy of an appraisal report, ensuring it meets necessary standards.
Identification Section This section requires details such as the project name, location, and type of property, allowing for clear identification of the appraisal being reviewed.
Types of Appraisal The form accommodates different appraisal types, including narrative and printed forms, which cater to various reporting preferences.
Value Sought Reviewers can specify the type of value sought, such as market value or other, which helps clarify the appraisal's intent.
Assumptions and Limiting Conditions This section allows the reviewer to note any assumptions or conditions that could affect the appraisal's validity, ensuring transparency.
Property Description Reviewers assess the adequacy of property descriptions, including physical features and zoning, to confirm that all relevant details are covered.
Valuation Approaches The form includes multiple valuation approaches, such as cost and income capitalization, enabling comprehensive analysis of the appraisal.
Final Rating Reviewers provide a final rating of the appraisal based on various criteria, helping to summarize the overall quality of the report.

Review Commercial Appraisal: Usage Guidelines

Filling out the Review Commercial Appraisal form requires careful attention to detail. This form serves as a structured way to assess the appraisal report for a specific property. Completing it accurately is essential for providing a comprehensive review.

  1. Begin by entering the Name of Project/Property in the designated space.
  2. Fill in the Location/Legal details of the property.
  3. Indicate the Type of Property by checking the appropriate box for either "Existing" or "Proposed Construction."
  4. Provide the Name of Appraiser and their Telephone number.
  5. Include the Address of the appraiser.
  6. Identify to whom the report is Addressed and include their Telephone and Address.
  7. Specify the Type of Appraisal Report by checking the relevant option (Narrative, Printed Form, or Other).
  8. In Section I, select the Value Sought and the Date of Value.
  9. Check the appropriate Interests Valued and any Assumptions and Limiting Conditions that apply.
  10. Provide Comments in the space provided in Section I.
  11. In Section II, answer the Yes/No/N/A questions regarding Property Identification, Ownership, and Assessment.
  12. Complete Section III by assessing whether the report adequately describes the Location Analysis.
  13. In Section IV, comment on the Property Description and provide feedback on the improvements and site.
  14. Evaluate the Highest and Best Use in Section V, answering the relevant questions.
  15. Rate the approaches to value in Section VI, including the Cost Approach, Income Capitalization Approach, and Sales Comparison Approach.
  16. In Section VII, confirm whether the report meets the necessary Other Report Requirements.
  17. Provide your final rating of the appraisal in Section VIII, noting any unacceptable ratings.
  18. Conclude in Section IX by summarizing your recommendations and signing as the reviewer.

Your Questions, Answered

What is the purpose of the Review Commercial Appraisal form?

The Review Commercial Appraisal form serves as a structured tool for evaluating the quality and accuracy of a commercial appraisal report. It helps reviewers assess various aspects of the appraisal, including property identification, valuation methods, and compliance with relevant standards. By using this form, reviewers can provide a clear and organized critique of the appraisal, ensuring that all necessary information has been adequately addressed.

What information is required to complete the form?

To complete the Review Commercial Appraisal form, several key details must be filled out. This includes the name of the project or property, its location, and the type of property (existing or proposed construction). The appraiser's name and contact information are also necessary. Additionally, the form requires the type of appraisal report, the value sought (e.g., market value), and the date of value. Other sections require information about property ownership, assessment history, and location analysis, among others.

How does the form evaluate the appraisal's valuation methods?

The form includes specific sections dedicated to evaluating the different approaches to valuation, such as the cost approach, sales comparison approach, and income capitalization approach. Each method is assessed for its adequacy, format, and the quality of data used. Reviewers are prompted to comment on the strengths and weaknesses of each approach, allowing for a comprehensive analysis of how the appraiser arrived at their conclusions.

What are the potential outcomes after completing the review?

After completing the review, the reviewer can conclude whether they accept or reject the appraisal. If the reviewer disagrees with the appraisal's conclusions, they can recommend actions such as reworking the appraisal or obtaining a new appraisal from a different appraiser. The form provides space for the reviewer to document their recommendations and any final comments, ensuring that all concerns are clearly communicated.

Is the Review Commercial Appraisal form legally binding?

The Review Commercial Appraisal form itself is not legally binding; rather, it serves as a professional assessment tool. It is intended to guide reviewers in evaluating appraisals and does not impose legal obligations. However, the conclusions drawn from the review may influence decisions related to financing, investment, or property transactions, making it an important document in the appraisal process.

Common mistakes

  1. Incomplete Property Information: Many people forget to fill in crucial details about the property, such as its location, type, and ownership. This information is essential for a thorough appraisal review.

  2. Missing Purpose of Appraisal: Not clearly stating the purpose of the appraisal can lead to confusion. Specify whether you're seeking market value or another type of valuation to avoid misunderstandings.

  3. Ignoring Assumptions and Limiting Conditions: Failing to address the assumptions and limiting conditions can result in an inaccurate appraisal. It’s important to acknowledge these factors to provide a complete picture.

  4. Overlooking Property Description: A common mistake is not providing enough detail about the property's physical features and improvements. A thorough description helps ensure that all aspects are considered in the appraisal.

  5. Neglecting to Review Valuation Approaches: Some individuals skip the section on valuation approaches. It's vital to comment on each method used, as this can significantly impact the appraisal's credibility.

Documents used along the form

The Review Commercial Appraisal form is an essential document used to assess the value of commercial properties. It serves as a framework for evaluating the quality and accuracy of an appraisal report. Along with this form, several other documents are frequently utilized to provide a comprehensive analysis of the property in question. Below is a list of five such forms and documents, each playing a crucial role in the appraisal process.

  • Appraisal Report: This document details the findings of the appraiser, including property descriptions, methodologies used, and the final valuation. It serves as the primary source of information for the Review Commercial Appraisal form.
  • Property Inspection Report: Conducted by the appraiser, this report provides an on-site evaluation of the property’s physical condition, including any issues that may affect its value. It often includes photographs and descriptions of improvements and deficiencies.
  • Market Analysis Report: This document analyzes current market trends, comparable sales, and economic factors influencing property values in the area. It helps contextualize the appraisal and supports the appraiser's conclusions.
  • Zoning and Land Use Documents: These documents outline the zoning regulations applicable to the property, including permitted uses and any restrictions. They are vital for determining the highest and best use of the property.
  • Sales Comparison Analysis: This analysis compares the subject property to similar properties that have recently sold in the market. It provides a basis for adjusting the appraisal based on market conditions and comparable property values.

In summary, these documents complement the Review Commercial Appraisal form, providing a holistic view of the property being assessed. Together, they facilitate a thorough evaluation process, ensuring that all relevant factors are considered in determining the property's value.

Similar forms

  • Appraisal Report: The Review Commercial Appraisal form closely mirrors the standard appraisal report, as both documents detail the property being assessed, including its location, ownership, and valuation methods.
  • Commercial Property Analysis: Similar to the Review Commercial Appraisal form, a commercial property analysis evaluates the market and physical characteristics of a property, providing insights into its investment potential.
  • Market Analysis Report: Both documents assess market conditions and trends. The Review Commercial Appraisal form includes a location analysis section, which is also a key component of market analysis reports.
  • Property Condition Report: This report focuses on the physical state of a property, much like the property description section in the Review Commercial Appraisal form, which addresses improvements and site conditions.
  • Feasibility Study: A feasibility study evaluates the viability of a project, similar to how the Review Commercial Appraisal form discusses the highest and best use of a property.
  • Investment Analysis Report: This type of report assesses the potential return on investment, akin to the income capitalization approach found in the Review Commercial Appraisal form.
  • Comparative Market Analysis (CMA): A CMA compares similar properties to determine value, paralleling the sales comparison approach detailed in the Review Commercial Appraisal form.
  • Zoning Analysis Report: This report examines zoning regulations affecting property use, similar to the zoning section in the Review Commercial Appraisal form that assesses conformity with local zoning laws.
  • Environmental Impact Report: Both documents may address potential environmental hazards affecting property value. The Review Commercial Appraisal form includes a section for identifying hazardous conditions.
  • Tax Assessment Report: This report provides information on property taxes and assessments, which is relevant to the Review Commercial Appraisal form’s section on real estate tax information.

Dos and Don'ts

When filling out the Review Commercial Appraisal form, attention to detail is essential. Here are nine important guidelines to follow, including actions to take and pitfalls to avoid.

  • Do ensure accuracy: Double-check all entries for correctness to avoid miscommunication.
  • Do provide complete information: Fill in all required fields, including property details and appraiser information.
  • Do use clear language: Write comments and notes that are straightforward and easy to understand.
  • Do keep it professional: Maintain a formal tone throughout the form to reflect the seriousness of the appraisal.
  • Don't skip sections: Every part of the form is important; leaving sections blank can lead to incomplete evaluations.
  • Don't use vague terms: Avoid ambiguous language; be specific about any concerns or observations.
  • Don't rush the process: Take your time to ensure thoroughness in your review and comments.
  • Don't forget to sign: Ensure that you and any other necessary parties sign the form to validate the review.
  • Don't neglect follow-up: If there are issues, be prepared to recommend further action or clarification as needed.

By adhering to these guidelines, you can help ensure that the Review Commercial Appraisal form is completed effectively and accurately, facilitating a smoother appraisal process.

Misconceptions

  • Misconception 1: The Review Commercial Appraisal form is only for existing properties.
  • This form is applicable to both existing and proposed constructions. It allows appraisers to evaluate the value of new developments just as thoroughly as established properties.

  • Misconception 2: The form only addresses market value.
  • While market value is a key focus, the form also accommodates other types of value, such as leased interest and market rent. This flexibility ensures that various valuation needs are met.

  • Misconception 3: The form is too complex for average users.
  • Though it contains detailed sections, the Review Commercial Appraisal form is designed to be user-friendly. Each section guides users through the appraisal process, making it accessible to those without extensive appraisal experience.

  • Misconception 4: All appraisal reports are created equal.
  • Not all appraisal reports meet the same standards. This form includes specific criteria to evaluate the quality and thoroughness of the appraisal, ensuring that only reliable reports are accepted.

  • Misconception 5: The form does not consider location analysis.
  • In fact, the form has a dedicated section for location analysis. It prompts reviewers to assess trends, nuisances, and hazards in the area, which are crucial for accurate property valuation.

  • Misconception 6: The Review Commercial Appraisal form is outdated.
  • This form is regularly updated to reflect current market conditions and appraisal practices. It remains a relevant tool for both appraisers and reviewers.

  • Misconception 7: The form does not require any qualifications from the appraiser.
  • On the contrary, the form explicitly asks for the appraiser's qualifications and requires their signature. This ensures accountability and professionalism in the appraisal process.

  • Misconception 8: The reviewer’s conclusions are not taken seriously.
  • The conclusions drawn by the reviewer carry significant weight. They can recommend actions such as revising the appraisal or obtaining a new one, emphasizing the importance of thorough review.

Key takeaways

  • Begin by clearly identifying the appraisal report. Include the project name, location, and type of property (existing or proposed).

  • Specify the appraiser's name and contact information. This ensures direct communication if any clarifications are needed.

  • Indicate the type of appraisal report being reviewed, whether it's a narrative, printed form, or another type.

  • Clearly state the value sought, such as market value, and provide the relevant date for that value.

  • Ensure that the report contains adequate property identification, including the legal description and ownership history.

  • Evaluate the location analysis section to confirm it discusses regional trends, nuisances, and hazards that may affect property value.

  • Review the property description for clarity on physical features, zoning, and any special problems that could impact the appraisal.

  • Assess the highest and best use section to ensure it aligns with zoning laws and marketability considerations.

  • Conclude by rating the appraisal’s overall quality, focusing on readability, mathematical accuracy, and the appraiser's analytical abilities.